Quality Resources for Multicultural Ministry and Biblical Exploration

Against Exaggerating the Importance of Contextualisation

Nicole Starling reflected on the way she and her husband found themselves accommodating their behaviour to that of the next-door neighbours they had round for a meal. Her sane approach to 1 Corinthians 9 provides a healthy counter-balance to the typical over-reading and over-application of this passage: Maybe the array of terms that Paul uses [...]

$ AUD

Nicole Starling reflected on the way she and her husband found themselves accommodating their behaviour to that of the next-door neighbours they had round for a meal. Her sane approach to 1 Corinthians 9 provides a healthy counter-balance to the typical over-reading and over-application of this passage:

  • Maybe the array of terms that Paul uses in 1 Corinthians 9:19-23 (“Jews”; “those under the law”; “those outside the law”; “the weak”, etc.) is not really a long list of examples of various cultural differences to be overcome by contextualization. Maybe in Paul’s situation, it all boils down to one issue: the impact of old covenant food and purity laws on who he is able to sit down and share a meal with.
  • Maybe the main application of that passage… is not about trying to look and sound more like my neighbours when we sit around the table talking; maybe it’s simply about overcoming the kind of preferences and prejudices that would stop me from sitting around a table with them at all.
  • Maybe I’ve been hiding behind “all things to all people” as an excuse for not obeying “let your light shine before others.”
  • Maybe I should focus a bit more on having dinner with the neighbours more often, and focus a bit less on trying not to look like the Flanders family when  I do.
  • Maybe I should pay a bit more attention to loving my neighbours, and pay a bit less attention to looking like them.

Source: Nicole Starling, “Contextualization vs. chameleonization” in The Briefing 371 (August 2009) 8

Posted April 9, 2011

www.facetofaceintercultural.com.au

Upon clicking 'Buy now' you will be redirected to paypal.com where you can securely and quickly complete your purchase with a few clicks.

Immediately after payment at PayPal you will be redirected to a download page which provides you instant access to your purchase.

Solution Graphics

Leave a Reply